Oracles of Science: Celebrity Scientists versus God and Religion Review

Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)Are you looking to buy Oracles of Science: Celebrity Scientists versus God and Religion? Here is the right place to find the great deals. we can offer discounts of up to 90% on Oracles of Science: Celebrity Scientists versus God and Religion. Check out the link below:

>> Click Here to See Compare Prices and Get the Best Offers

Oracles of Science: Celebrity Scientists versus God and Religion Review`Oracles of Science' is a good book. No doubt Giberson and Artigas are knowledgeable scientists and they argue their case with care and subtlety. There are however a few reservations to be made.
Firstly, I find the major idea of the book unconvincing. In criticizing the popular books by Dawkins, Gould, Hawking, Sagan, Weinberg and Wilson, they assert that scientists should not be allowed to `trespass' into other areas than their science proper. There is a lot of talk about unwarranted conclusions, improper speculations and the well-known `naturalistic fallacy'. But these are popular science books and why on earth should the authors be prohibited to philosophize and speculate about god knows what (pun intended)? That, in my opinion, is precisely what makes these books so interesting - and successful. The authors are not abusing science, they are just putting forward their personal opinions. If that were not the case the books would make for boring reading indeed.
Which leads to the second reservation. It seems to me that whenever there is critique of religion and faith, believers easily get their feelings hurt. Giberson and Artigas talk of hostility to God, vicious attacks on religion and so forth as if it were a deadly sin. They portray some of the authors as being either simpletons or `evolution evangelists' and `secular priests'. `Weinberg is simply pontificating from his platform of prestige, without seriously engaging these difficult issues' p. 184. Do I sense a little professional jealousy here?
Thirdly, I'd like to say something about the quotation on p. 14. where Richard Dawkins is charging that people who don't believe in evolution are `stupid, wicked or insane'. They had to dig deep to find that, but it's all there on the Internet. The quotation comes from a book review in the New York Times from 1989 (!). In a discussion of whether creationism should be given equal time in biology classes as evolution, Dawkins says: `...if you meet somebody who claims not to believe in evolution, that person is ignorant, stupid or insane (or wicked, but I'd rather not consider that).' The next sentence is: `If that gives you offence, I'm sorry.'
I always thought that when you quote something, you must be absolutely certain that the quotation is correct. But maybe, like Dawkins, I'm also becoming a museum piece (p. 52).
Lastly, on the back cover journalist Larry Witham claims that this book also cautions believers against a similar abuse (i.e. trespassing) of science. Well, I'm sorry but I must have missed out on that - maybe the meticulous reader can find some references to that effect.
These qualms aside, `Oracles of Science' is a serious and thought-provoking book, well worth reading.
Oracles of Science: Celebrity Scientists versus God and Religion OverviewBiologists Stephen Jay Gould, Richard Dawkins, and Edward O. Wilson, and physicists Carl Sagan, Stephen Hawking, and Steven Weinberg have become public intellectuals, articulating a much larger vision for science and what role it should play in the modern worldview.The scientific prestige and literary eloquence of each of these great thinkers combine to transform them into what can only be called oracles of science. Curiously, the leading "oracles of science" are predominantly secular in ways that don't reflect the distribution of religious beliefs within the scientific community. Many of them are even hostile to religion, creating a false impression that science as a whole is incompatible with religion. Karl Giberson and Mariano Artigas offer an informed analysis of the views of these six scientists, carefully distinguishing science from philosophy and religion in the writings of the oracles.

Want to learn more information about Oracles of Science: Celebrity Scientists versus God and Religion?

>> Click Here to See All Customer Reviews & Ratings Now